Originally Posted by
Brodie Butland
Yeah. I think that most trainers honestly care about the vast majority of their clients. But one problem is they don't know what they don't know, and they can't help if they don't know how. Blame the "big 5" personal training certs for this one, who have more or less been co-opted by The Literature and the latest exercise "science" (fads).
The other big problem is that many don't understand the concept of a measurable goal independent of aesthetics. "Being healthier" or "feeling better," for example, aren't measurable goals, at least in the long term. Sure, short term you may see things like significant weight loss, better lipid profiles, or more energy...but once you reach a baseline level of "health" or "feeling," what next? In normal PT world, "what next?" is invariably some nebulous concept of "fitness" that involves constant changing of exercises, balancing on bosu balls, and other things plucked from the latest garbage-in-garbage-out Ex Fizz studies, none of which provides an objectively measurable benefit.
One of the big selling points to the Starting Strength methodology is that it provides a goal (becoming stronger), the progression of which uses easily measurable and objective parameters (did the weight on the bar increase? did you do more reps?), that has significant carry-over to better functioning in everyday life. Someone who deadlifts 405 and does a modest cardio supplement will have an easier time moving boxes, shoveling the driveway, playing recreational sports, playing with the kids/grandkids, and doing chores around the house than someone who deadlifts under two plates and does a lot of "functional training" for "general fitness." This is why SS Gyms and SS Coaches are so damn busy...once a client sees the change in their lives after modest lifting gains, they become true believers--and then they recruit others.