
Originally Posted by
Kyle Aaron
Callador, the guy was benching 80kg with his thighs perpedicular to the bench, feet in the air, and his pelvis tilted back. When asked why he did it, he said it was because he wanted to make it less stable. He wants to be unstable with roughly his bodyweight over his face and neck. Go try that in WFAC and see what happens.
The law is that we have a duty of care towards the people in our gym. That means that our offering instruction is mandatory for us if we believe the person is placing themselves or others in danger. It also means that if they refuse that instruction, we are required to kick them out. Because if we don't, then when they do injure themselves and sue us, we'll lose. Remember also that 2/3 of new gym members don't seek instruction before starting out, but they do copy what they see others doing in the gym. So the stupidity of one fuckstick spreads, and I have to spend half my shift dealing with people doing stupid shit. Because if I don't, when they get injured and sue us, they'll say, "Well, I saw this other guy doing it, the PT talked to him and the guy kept doing it, so I thought it was alright, and the PT never talked to me, I thought it was alright... and now I'm crippled, give me $2 million please."
This may offend the libertarian sensibilities of those here on this forum, but that's the law, at least in practice. If we don't follow it, we risk losing our jobs and the company the contract to run the gym, or the gym itself closes down. All because some dickhead wanted to bench with his feet flapping in the fucking air. I'm sorry, but your right to be a stupid fuck and injure yourself does not trump my need to put bread on my family's table. Go do it someplace else.
Any exercise should be both safe and effective. But the main thing is safety. When I see people half-squatting and they ignore my coaching, well fair enough - it's not effective, but it's safe, so it's up to them. But benching with your feet in the air or round-backed deadlifting is not safe. So we have to stop them. If it were up to me I'd just let them injure and kill themselves, it improves the gene pool. But I want to keep my job and the gym open.
You may not want some random trainer telling you what to do, but when you pay for a gym membership that's actually what you're paying for. My gym has 5,000 people paying around $20 a week each. That's $100,000 a week. That's sure as shit not all going on equipment and lighting - it's wages. If you wish to avoid the risk of being told what to do, train at home. By going into a gym, you accept the possibility that someone will try to tell you what to do. You can ignore it if you want - provided it's still safe.
Safe and effective. If you want to do exercises which are ineffective, go for it. Most gym members do that. But if you want to do exercises which are unsafe, you'll have to train at home.
Again, try benching with your feet in the air at WFAC and see what Rip and Stef have to say to you. When they argue and don't back down, try insulting one of the other gym members and telling them not to listen to Rip. "I've got the right to train here without some random coach telling me how to lift." See what happens.
Bookmarks