Originally Posted by
Michael Wolf
He also displays some very strong characteristics; I can buy that 60 year old Luke wouldn't be as optimistic as 20-25 year old Luke, and would be more jaded, but his essential character was discarded. This was a guy who was willing to sacrifice everything to try to redeem his father, the face of evil in the galaxy, a man who had personally killed thousands of people and ordered and supervised the deaths of millions or billions more, all because he still sensed some good and conflict within him. But then we're supposed to believe he would contemplate and then almost try to kill his nephew - the son of his best friend and his sister - because he sensed he might become evil, even though he hadn't done any of that suff yet?!? This is the main issue I have with LimieJosh's post - it has a grain of truth, and an older jaded Luke who knows he isn't strong enough to defeat Snoke/Kylo alone could have been an interesting story, and a good place to bring Rey in. Completely disregarding his essential character and Hero's Journey? That was dumb, and what many rightfully find unforgivable.