I kind of enjoyed the ACFT.
I think that the "good" aspects of the new test are the gender neutral standards and the tying of minimum scores to specific jobs in the Army. Some of the events are lame, but it's hard to argue that an infantryman should be able to drag something heavy. The trap bar is dumb; but I do like the leg tuck more than situps. And the two mile run is clearly in there so our marathon running generals don't get too embarrassed.
I'm pretty sure everyone here will blow me up, but I have really enjoyed the "tests" that Rob Shaul put together at Military Athlete. I've done all of the ones below and I have to believe if you're able to do well on these tests you can probably do any military task:
Operator Ugly Fitness Test - Mountain Tactical Institute
MTI's Tactical Athlete Work Capacity Assessment - Mountain Tactical Institute
It would be cool to see what Mark et al. would think a good military PFT would consist of.