I smiled when I saw your post, Satch. I was a decent musician as a kid, so I thought WSS was the coolest damned thing I'd ever seen second only to the Apollo missions and my first Amoeba under a microscope. We didn't project "gay" or "hetero" on everything back then.
BUT....trying to understand where Hurling is coming from, I searched the topic and look at what we find today: Inside West Side Story
Did we have to do that to West Side Story? Sigh. I guess Peppermind Patty (Charlie Brown) was transgender also?Infused throughout West Side Story is a gay sensibility that’s expressed subtextually in the relationship between the hero Tony and Riff, the leader of the Jets, and choreographically through the homoeroticism of the all-male dance sequences. Equally bold is the inclusion of the character named Anybodys, a teenage girl who identifies as a male and longs to be accepted as a full member of the Jets. Anybodys is Broadway’s first transgender youth.
So, credit to Hurling for being less of a boomer than I am...more "with it".
Still, gay or hetero, I always thought this captured the essence of first (instant) love for a young man: West Side Story: Maria
My mom was in Nuremberg during the trials as she was part of the US forces there. I'll check out Judgement tonight.