Originally Posted by
Hassan Mansour
If you start watching lots and lots of squats on social media and in most gyms, you'll find that "push the knees forward" is a pretty good cue for lots of people regardless of whether it's high-bar or low-bar squats you are looking at.
Lots of people are under the impression that you have to squat with nearly vertical shins and muscle up weights with your back when things get heavy. This obviously isn’t correct.
Some people even show up to the Starting Strength seminars and try to squat with nearly vertical shins and this drives Rip and the staff pretty crazy, too. The knees forward thing is discussed in the book both in the squat and front squat chapters/sections.
In fact, I specifically remember Rip making someone rack the bar after watching them attempt to squat with nearly vertical shins and yelling out "this isn't Westside, you have to bend your knees in order to squat." Ha!
After the novice phase, for some lifters, throwing in some variants that "emphasize the quads" is usually suitable for lifters who have trouble with the proprioceptive aspect of driving the knees forwards properly and "using their quads". Front squats, pin squats, SSB squats, or belt squats would be decent variants for this particular situation depending on the lifter and the program. Lots of intermediate/advanced lifters who don't have this problem can get by without any of those variants and just stick to plain ol’ squats, paused squats, etc. without any particular "quad emphasis".
Not quite sure how any of this is supposed to be controversial.