WFAC Strengthlifting Challenge
Hello guys. Had ascending aortic aneurysm. They did surgery in Dec 2017. I started strength training 1 year ago. It's been brought to my attention that might not be a good idea. Any input would be greatly appreciated.
Was the repair successful?
Absolutely Rip
Then what is he worried about?
I think because the blood pressure rises when we try moving a heavy load? I've been training for a year and feel great, so i'm going to continue doing the program. Thank you for the input Rip.
The Valsalva & Stroke
I seem to recall an early episode of Starting Strength Radio where a heart surgeon explained that the most stress your heart will ever be under is on his table. If you survived that, his opinion was to train away.
All I've been hearing is to take it easy. Don't want to. Appreciate the advice. Train away, I will.
Rip, a question about your Olympic lifts podcast. You said someone who deadlifts 700 is stronger than some who clean and jerks 200. What about someone who rack pulls 1000? Are they stronger than the deadlifter and the o-lifter?
Maybe. But remember that the ROM of a rack pull is shorter.
And deadlift ROM is shorter than clean and jerk ROM.
Yes, it is.
If you can only deadlift 250 lbs. 200 lb clean will be real, real hard. A 250 lb clean just won’t happen. Ever! So if you can deadlift 700 lbs, a 200 lb clean will be easy and so will a 250 lb clean. A rack pull is an assistant exercise for deads. If you're loading up 1000lbs on it, you're doing it wrong. It’s also only meant to help you hold your back in extension. Maybe help get the ass through to the finish. I have limited experience with cleans but can still clean and jerk 225 lbs with the worst form this side of ever.
Maybe Rip can weigh in on this but I don't think a 1000 lb rack pull would be useless. Even if it's pulled with less ROM, the amount of force provided is immense and capable of a physiological adaptation. Or am I wrong?
Try them and report back.
Rack pulls won’t increase Jack. I’ve been there done that with dead’s. I did rack pulls for six weeks instead of dead’s. Dead’s went backwards. It will only help hold position, thereby indirectly helping dead’s go up because of better technique or addressed weaknesses. Yeah sure if you only add 20 lbs to your dead won’t help but if you add 100 of 200. That max clean just got easier off the floor. But with all that said, the clean must be trained in order for it to go up. Do dead’s help. Yes! Rack pulls. No! It’s too short a motion. Because it’s a short motion the weight gets inflated.
That has not been my experience.
Meat –Jim Steel
The White Noise of Heavy –Carl Raghavan
Highlights from the StartingStrength Community. Browse archives.